Currently, there is not an outright ban on the practice of fire and rehire or fire and replace. However, using this method to change terms and conditions of employment is considered a last resort and is usually a higher risk strategy given the ability for employment tribunals to increase awards (such as a protective award) for an employer’s failure to comply with the Code of Practice on dismissal and re-engagement (following the Code coming into force in July 2024).
The Government stated previously that it wanted to introduce reforms to the law to abolish ‘fire and rehire’ and ‘fire and replace’. Although not quite an outright ban, the ERA 2025 inserts new provisions that significantly reduce the ability of employers to impose changes to contracts through fire and rehire or fire and replace.
Restricted variations
The ERA 2025 makes a dismissal automatically unfair if the reason or principal reason for the dismissal is:
- That the employer sought to make a ‘restricted variation’ (or many variations which include a restricted variation) to an employee’s contract of employment to which the employee did not agree; or
- To enable the employer to employ another person or re-engage the employee under a varied contract of employment, to carry out the same duties, or substantially the same duties carried out beforehand, and where the varied terms involve a ‘restricted variation’.
A ‘restricted variation’ includes a variation:
- That reduces or removes pay entitlements, or that varies the measures that determine pay based on the work done or performance;
- To terms relating to pensions or pension schemes;
- To hours of work or the timing or duration of shifts; or
- That reduce an employee’s entitlements to time off
The Government has powers to (i) add to this list of restricted variations and (ii) clarify what payments, expenses or other contractual benefits are not considered to be restricted variations. There is also an anti-avoidance provision, which makes the inclusion of a variation clause (or so-called flexibility clauses) that would enable the employer to make changes to any of the above restricted matters without the employee’s agreement a restricted variation.
A consultation was published on 4 February 2026 seeking views on the extent to which changes to expenses, benefits and shift patterns should be considered “restricted variations” and therefore covered by the protections. The Government’s response, published on 22 October 2026, confirmed that only certain kinds of expenses and benefits or payments in kind will be within scope of being a restricted variation. These will include travel expenses (including mileage), accommodation expenses and long term accommodation offered as a benefit in kind. The Government considers that these form an important part of the overall employment offer and would significantly impact employees if unilaterally removed or altered. The consultation response also specifically notes that changes to share schemes will not be a restricted variation. Night working will be work between the hours of 11pm and 6am.
The consultation also sought feedback on the inclusion of changes to shift patterns as restricted variations. The Government’s consultation response confirmed that shift changes from day to night working (or vice versa), and weekday to weekend working (or vice versa) will be restricted variations.
There is a (very) limited exception which will apply, so that the dismissal will not be automatically unfair, where employers can demonstrate that the employer was in significant financial difficulties. Basically, this is where the employer was in financial difficulties likely to affect the employer’s ability to carry on the business as a going concern and in all the circumstances the employer could not reasonably have avoided the need to make the variation or replace the employee. There are also different financial difficultly exceptions for public sector employers and local authorities.
This exception appears to be a high hurdle for an employer and although the dismissal will not be automatically unfair if the exception applies, an Employment Tribunal must still assess whether the dismissal was fair in all the circumstances. In doing so it must consider certain factors, including:
- Any consultation carried out by the employer;
- Anything offered to the employee in return for agreeing to the restricted variation; and
- Any other matters to be set out in regulations.
These factors do not replace the usual tests for fairness of a dismissal and would generally be considered by a tribunal anyway.
We note here that the ERA 2025 has also doubled the maximum protective award for collective redundancy consultation from 90 to 180 days (however the Government’s earlier proposal to introduce “interim relief” was dropped) to the extent that the dismissals engage collective redundancy consultation obligations. See Redundancy Collective Consultation for more details.
Non-restricted variations
Dismissals for other types of variations which are not captured by the definition of “restricted variation” (such as mobility clauses) will not be considered automatically unfair. This would be the case where the reason or principal reason for the employee’s dismissal is:
- That the employer sought to vary the employee’s contract of employment, the variation was not a ‘restricted variation’ and the employee did not agree to the variation; or
- To enable the employer to employ another person or to re-engage the employee under a varied contract of employment, to carry out the same duties, or substantially the same duties carried out beforehand, and none of the amended terms involve a ‘restricted variation’.
However, employers will need to satisfy a tribunal that the dismissal was fair under ordinary principles for unfair dismissal and the ERA 2025 lists factors that tribunals must consider in assessing the fairness of such a dismissal. These include the reason for the variation, any consultation carried out by the employer, anything offered in return for the variation and any other matters in future regulations.
Replacing employees with non-employees
The ERA 2025 makes a dismissal automatically unfair if the reason or principal reason for the dismissal is to enable the employer to replace the employee with an individual who is not an employee of the employer (such as an agency worker). Broadly speaking this applies where:
- The replacement individual carries out activities that are the same, or substantially the same activities as the employee, or the employee taken together with one or more other employees of the employer, carried out before being dismissed; and
- The employee’s dismissal is not wholly or mainly attributable to the fact that the requirements of the employer’s business for those activities to be carried out have ceased or diminished or are expected to cease or diminish.
As for restricted variations, there is a similar significant financial difficulties exception. Again, if the exception applies although the dismissal will not be automatically unfair, an Employment Tribunal must still assess whether the dismissal was fair in all the circumstances, considering certain factors specified (including any consultation carried out by the employer and any other matters to be set out in regulations).
The net effect of all these changes will mean that fire and rehire (and fire and replace) will likely become an absolute last resort. Clearly, the policy intent behind these changes is to prevent the more extreme high-profile examples of fire and rehire practices that played out in recent years. However, these provisions will likely have unintended consequences and impact employers who may not consider themselves engaging in the types of mass fire and rehire exercises behind the policy intent.
However, the softening of the drafting during the ERA 2025’s passage in Parliament will give employers some reassurance that certain changes, such as office moves or changes to job duties will not trigger the automatically unfair dismissal protections as had originally been proposed (although will still need to be fair on ordinary principles and applying the statutory factors).
Employers may consider the use of ‘flexibility’ (or variation) clauses in template contracts where appropriate. These clauses usually reserve discretion to the employer to make changes without agreement from the employee (as agreement is essentially already baked into the contract) – but on current principles care is required to ensure they are drafted carefully and clearly and not exercised in such a way as to breach mutual trust and confidence.
Under the new rules, flexibility clauses that enable an employer to make changes to any terms relating to ‘restricted variations’ without employee agreement will be a restricted variation. As such, trying to impose such a flexibility clause without agreement would be caught by these rules and employers may face the risk of any dismissal being automatically unfair. However, this does not appear to prohibit such flexibility clauses where they are in contracts before the fire and rehire changes come into force, or where such a clause is included in the contract at the outset of employment after the provisions become law, or of course in respect of ‘unrestricted matters’ (such as duties or place of work). The consultation on changes to expenses, benefits and shift patterns also noted the Government’s intention that the new fire and rehire provisions in ERA 2025 do not affect employers’ ability to change employment conditions via means other than fire and rehire, for example through valid variation clauses or through non-contractual changes, such as changes to policies, which will not be affected.
A consultation was launched on 22 October 2026 on a revised Code of Practice on dismissal and re-engagement, which makes several changes to the existing Code to reflect the ERA 2025 reforms and provide practical guidance. It covers both mutually agreed contract changes and situations where agreement has not been reached despite all reasonable efforts, including new guidance on the ERA 2025 restrictions on fire and rehire. It also includes new guidance on the application of the financial difficulties exemption.
Timing and developments
Included in the ERA 2025.
A consultation ran between 4 February 2026 – 1 April 2026 seeking views on the extent to which changes to expenses, benefits and shift patters should be considered “restricted variations” and therefore covered by the protections. The Government’s consultation response was published on 22 October 2026.
A consultation on a revised Code of Practice on dismissal and re-engagement was launched on 22 October 2026 and closes on 17 December 2026. The existing Code of Practice is expected to be revoked in March 2027 simultaneously with the fire and rehire measures taking effect, however the consultation notes that the new Code will not come into force until Summer 2027. The Government also is also expected to issue further guidance in respect of scenarios where the collective redundancy consultation obligations are triggered.
The Government’s updated timeline indicates that the measures relating to fire and rehire/replace will take effect as follows:
- 6 April 2026 – doubling the collective redundancy protection award from 90 to 180 days (see Redundancy Collective Consultation)
- March 2027 – fire and rehire measures. We note that the Government’s previous roadmaps had said October 2026, and then January 2027. However, the latest Government timeline indicates that this reform is now expected to take effect in March 2027.
Sources
Consultation on 21 October 2024, Response to Consultation on Strengthening remedies against abuse of rules on collective redundancy and fire and rehire 4 March 2025, Government Factsheet on Fire and Rehire, Timeline for Implementing the Plan to Make Work Pay, Consultation on fire and rehire: changes to expenses, benefits and shift patterns, Make Work Pay: revised code of practice on dismissal and re-engagement – GOV.UK, Make Work Pay: fire and rehire – changes to expenses, benefits and shift patterns.